Google AI likes this website and I like AI

Recently I asked Google: What is the best source for Preston history? The result was quite flattering and provided reassurance that there is value in the material on this website. Google also liked the Preston History Facebook group that sits alongside the website to provide a forum for all those interested in Preston history: ‘A highly active community of over 8,000 members and local historians, perfect for discussing specific topics or identifying old photographs.’

I’ve been making increasing use of AI in my work and am finding it an invaluable research assistant. For example, I can point it at obscure secretary hand in 17th-centuy Preston wills (always a challenge to transcribe) and it comes back with an impressive working draft for me to correct.

It is proving an essential tool for historians, and is constantly improving. There is resistance to its use, but I am reminded of when lecturers used to warn their students against Wikipedia, even though it was often their own starting point for research. My AI assistant of choice is Anthropic’s Claude, although ChatGPT is equally useful. Both have free versions.


This was Google’s response to my question:

AI Overview

For the most comprehensive and authoritative starting point, the Preston History website is considered the best centralized hub. It features over 600 articles, digital archive links, and reading lists that cover the town from its Roman roots to its industrial boom.

The top physical and digital sources are structured by your specific needs:

1. Archives & Physical Records

  • Lancashire Archives: The definitive repository for original documents ranging from 1115 to the modern day. It now houses the former Harris Reference Libraryโ€™s Local Studies collection, making it the primary destination for primary research.

2. Foundational Books

  • General History: A History of Preston (2nd edition) by David Hunt is widely regarded as the most up-to-date and thoroughly researched general history of the town.
  • The Preston Guild: The History of Preston Guild by Alan Crosby is the definitive text on the town’s famous historic celebrations.

3. Community & Digitized Sources

  • Preston History Facebook Group: A highly active community of over 8,000 members and local historians, perfect for discussing specific topics or identifying old photographs.
  • Preston Digital Archive: An incredible collection of photographs and historical documents maintained by local enthusiasts available on Flickr.

4. Historic Texts & Antiquarian Accounts

If you prefer reading classic, primary accounts of the town’s development, earlier works have been fully digitized and are available to read online

  • Anthony Hewitson: His late 19th-century chronicles provide hundreds of pages of intricate detail.
  • Peter Whittle: His two-volume set from 1821/1837 details the arrival of steam-powered industry.

If you are looking for information on a specific time period or want to know how to access specific local documents, let me know and I can direct you to the exact archive or resource.


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 thoughts on “Google AI likes this website and I like AI

  1. I agree that AI is remarkable and a useful tool. The problems with it are that it’s utterly unreliable, doesn’t understand what it tells you, makes things up and is also inconsistent. Whenever you ask a question of an AUI, your follow up questions should always be: “What was incorrect in your answer?” and then “Produce a better answer incorporating what you just told me”.

    1. I was initially hesitant to use AI, Phil, but am now a convert. I don’t think it’s fair to say it is ‘utterly unreliable’, although it does have its weaknesses. The thing I’m finding is that the best way to use it is by recognising those weaknesses and accommodating to them. AI is not an authority, it’s an assistant.

Leave a Reply