Preston’s WW1 conscientious objectors

The Imperial War Museum’s Lives of the First World War website contains records of nearly eight million individuals, of whom 16,502 are listed as conscientious objectors. Twenty-two of those conscientious objectors were living in Preston, with another living in Lostock Hall.

The website provides some or all of the following information about those individuals: year of birth; address; political affiliations; religion; motivation and reason for their objection; and details of their various tribunal and court martial decisions and verdicts.

Part of a portrait of Joseph Garstang, painted by the artist Patti Mayor.
Part of a portrait of Joseph Garstang, painted by the artist Patti Mayor. https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7646268#gallery-5

For one of those conscientious objectors, Joseph ‘Joe’ Garstang, we know a great deal more thanks to research carried out by his great-niece Anne Berry. Joe held to his beliefs right to the end of the war, despite being jailed and force fed. His treatment led to questions being raised in parliament.

Joe’s biography and a link to an article Anne wrote about her great-uncle can be found here, along with several more photographs of Joe: Joseph Garstang (1888-1928).

The information about Joe and his fellow Preston conscientious objectors shows that they lived in the working-class districts of the town and their occupations put them firmly among the working class:

Apprentice painter, boot repairer and shoe repairer, building trade, carriage painter, clogger (2), commercial traveller, cotton spinner, cotton weaver, draper, labourer, market gardener, railway goods clerk, sewing machine salesman, tailor, traveller and pork butcher, and weaver.

Unlike in other parts of Lancashire, the motivation of the Preston men would seem to have been religious rather than political, with six Quakers forming the largest group. Eight of the men were jailed. Joe Garstang and another Preston man, Frederick Parr of Moss Croft, Lostock Hall, went on hunger strike while imprisoned.

Harry Ainsworth. Copy of photograph the original of which was taken before the advent of the Great War
Harry Ainsworth. Copy of photograph the original of which was taken before the advent of the Great War
https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7647159

Among those motivated by political objections to conscription was Harry Ainsworth, of 25, Balcarres Road, who was a member of the Preston branch of the Independent Labour Party and a Cloggers’ Union delegate to Preston Trades Council. He was jailed with hard labour.

Harry returned to Preston after the war, married and had at least one child. He died on 9 November 1969 and is buried in St Andrew’s RC Church, Cottam.

Cemetery headstone of Harry Ainsworth Headstone is situated in the graveyard of St Andrew's RC Church, Cottam, Preston, Lancs. UK. Harry was aged 83 when he died
Cemetery headstone of Harry Ainsworth. Headstone is situated in the graveyard of St Andrew’s RC Church, Cottam. Harry was aged 83 when he died.
https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7647159

Religious belief motivated James Oswald Beardsworth, a member of the Plymouth Brethren. He lived at 10 Bloomfield Street with his brother Harold, who was also a conscientious objector; Harold’s religion is not given.

Another Preston conscientious objector was Walter Holden, a Baptist, who lived at 9, Goldfinch Street in Deepdale. He was secretary of the Preston branch of the No-Conscription Fellowship, set up at the beginning of the war.

Among the leading figures in the fellowship was the suffragette Sylvia Pankhurst (my favourite Pankhurst). Preston’s suffragettes did not follow her when she determined to ‘to orchestrate her own war against war’. The conscientious objectors suffered similar treatment from the government to that meted out to the suffragettes, including force feeding and the use of the infamous Cat and Mouse Act.


Links
For details on all the Preston men
For a more detailed discussion


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 thoughts on “Preston’s WW1 conscientious objectors

  1. I am leading a project researching WW2 in Ashton-on-Ribble and have already interviewed the son of two conscientious objectors. I would be interested to know if similar records were maintained for WW2.
    Preston Quaker Meeting does not appear to have any in its archives.
    Stephen Davies

Leave a Reply