On this day … 6 October 1900

The Preston Guardian announced the defeat of James Keir Hardie, the Independent Labour Party candidate in the general election. He had stood for one of the town’s two parliamentary seats against two Tory opponents in what was known as the Khaki Election, with the Tories fighting on a jingoistic platform claiming imminent victory in the Boer War.

Keir Hardie had contested hard, clearly hoping to gather Liberal votes, that party having given up fighting Preston parliamentary elections after getting on for forty years of Tory dominance in the town. He would also, as a lifelong teetotaller, have been hoping for the votes of his fellow teetotallers in the town.

It was also an election with its own Murdoch moment, when the Liberal proprietor of the Lancashire Daily Post, George Toulmin, slapped down his editor for penning an attack on Keir Hardie, forcing him to publish a follow up making it clear that he had been expressing a personal view, certainly not that of his proprietor.

While defeated in Preston, Keir Hardie was successful in Wales where he was elected as MP for Merthyr Tydfil. In those days, it was possible to stand for more than one constituency.

Keir Hardie had not put himself forward for the Welsh seat, it was his supporters in the town who had nominated him. So, in the seat where he fought so hard, he was defeated and in the one where he was the absent candidate he succeeded.

Preston’s teetotallers should have favoured Keir Hardie, for he had signed the pledge himself at the age of seventeen, and temperance, it has been recently suggested, was his first political cause, in his native Scotland:

The suggestion comes in an article on the Keir Hardie Society website, prompted by an episode of Melvin Bragg’s ‘In Our Time’ programme, in which Annemarie McAllister from UCLan took part:

‘In Keir Hardie’s time, drink flourished among the very poor and was probably a bigger problem than drugs are today. Hardie’s stepfather could be abusive when drunk, and drink was a strong tradition in certain trades, including shipbuilding and mining.

‘Keir Hardie and his mother believed that drink was a widespread social evil that had to be countered by social action. They saw hope in the temperance movement that had been strong in Scotland since the 1840s. Hardie took the pledge when he was seventeen. The movement was not just a puritanical and religious movement. It was strongly associated with radical liberalism and the early socialists … It was also a significant social movement with libraries and friendly societies.

‘Temperance was arguably Hardie’s first political cause. He campaigned for the strict enforcement of existing laws and legal prohibition …

‘Many of his policy prescriptions may sound dated today, but they are not a long way from the solutions advocated by many to the drugs problem today. However, it was an uphill battle, as many Liberals regarded legislation on this issue as a challenge to their freedoms.

‘Hardie’s instincts sided with state control, a precursor of his later conversion to socialism. In parliament, he supported … proposals to shut down the local liquor trade. “Those who can take a glass or let it alone,” he said, are “under moral obligation for the sake of weaker brethren who cannot do so, to let it alone”.’


Sources
The Keir Hardie Society website: https://www.keirhardiesociety.org/blog/temperance-movement
Andrew Hobbs, A Fleet Street in Every Town: https://www.openbookpublishers.com/books/10.11647/obp.0152
Melvin Bragg’s programme: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0013zl8


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply