Simon Jenkins’ new book

Praise and a pillorying for the work
of Preston’s Building Design Partnership

A new book by the leading architectural historian Simon Jenkins celebrates the survival of Preston Bus Station, the city’s Brutalist masterpiece. But Jenkins has some very unflattering comments about other work by the Building Design Partnership (BDP) and its former chairman, the late Keith Scott.

Jenkin’s book, which was published at the end of last year, is A Short History of British Architecture: From Stonehenge to the Shard. It’s not that short, by the way, running to 320 pages.

On the fate of so many Brutalist buildings, he writes: ‘The cost of erecting buildings unable to survive one generation of use was ridiculous.’

Simon Jenkins' new book on British Architecture
Simon Jenkins’ new book

On the output from BDP, he writes: ‘The firm was responsible for some of the dreariest schools, universities, hospitals and public buildings back to the early 1960s.’

Jenkins quotes from an interview Keith Scott gave to the architectural writer Owen Hatherley shortly before his death in 2015:

‘Keith Scott, was remarkably frank. He admitted that the postwar period “was a disastrous period … we had to produce a building stock quite quickly, with cheap methods … we produced a lot of shoddy architecture.” When Hatherley asked him whether his approach to style changed in the 1970s and 80s, he said, “I don’t think anything to do with style entered my head.” He confessed to being a fan of Prince Charles.’

Preston bus station
Preston Bus Station before its recent facelift. What would be King Charles’ verdict? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Preston_bus_station_232-26.jpg

This is what Jenkins writes about the fate of Britain’s post-war Brutalist buildings, including Preston bus station:

‘Eight of the twelve “candidates for demolition” in a 2005 television series on most-hated British buildings were brutalist. They included Park Hill, Gateshead’s Trinity Car Park and Cumbernauld new town. Almost all are no more. Pressure to demolish the Hayward Gallery failed and Preston Bus Station was saved, but Portsmouth’s Tricorn Centre, Edinburgh’s St James Centre, half of London’s Robin Hood Gardens and John Madin’s Birmingham Central Library all went. The cost of erecting buildings unable to survive one generation of use was ridiculous.’

Returning to Preston bus station, if the young Keith Scott had been consulted about the siting of a new bus station for the town, it would not be sitting where it is today. According to Scott’s son, Tarquin, when his father was a student at Liverpool University’s School of Architecture: ‘His final year thesis in 1949 was for a new combined rail and bus station in Preston (something many still argue for) and he was awarded the coveted Pilkington Prize as “Top Student”.’

Overleigh House Preston
Overleigh House, the home of the late Keith Scott. Probably more to King Charles’ taste

Lancashire County Library has an e-book edition of Jenkins’ book available on BorrowBox.


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 thoughts on “Simon Jenkins’ new book

  1. Stonehenge is rather brutalist isn’t it and lasted more than a generation or two.

    Incidentally, I went to school in the 1960s near BDP’s offices. I would walk by the windows each day aspiring to such a clean and modern working environment. The irony that they were housed in a former working mill of our industrial heritage was not lost on me—and the dream was happily realised.

  2. Hi Peter,

    As part of the difficult process of leaving Overleigh after 61 years I have come across 2 audio CDs which may be of background interest to your researches. Both are radio interviews with Keith Scott.

    The first is an interview was done in 1982 on Radio Lancashire and is about 10 -12 minutes long and my father does talk about the working philosophy of the business.

    The other is with KPCW in for National Public Radio in Park City, Utah, and lasts about an hour. It’s a sort of ‘Desert Island Discs’ show, mostly featuring his favourite classical music pieces. I’ve not listened to it for years and was probably recorded in the early 1990s. But dad being dad, it probably also mentions BDP and architecture.

    You are welcome to come and see me and perhaps copy these items on to an info stick for listening to in your own time. My mobile #is 07875.645434.

    Best wishes, Tarquin Scott.

Leave a Reply