On this day … 8 September 1349

On 8 September 1349, the Black Death arrived in Preston, and between then and 11 January, 1350, it claimed an estimated three thousand victims in the parish, making a total of 13,180 deaths in Preston and its nine neighbouring parishes.

The dates and the number of victims need to be treated with caution for they rest on a solitary contemporary document. That does not mean that the impact was not devastating. The disruption it brought to normal life continued for many years after.

The figure of 3,000 dead was recorded and survived only because a dispute about money between two senior clerics left a trace amongst โ€˜several pieces of parchment not arranged in their correct orderโ€™ in the Public Record Office in London. These were discovered in the 19th century. The relevant items were โ€˜Two pieces of thick parchment, containing the numbers of vacancies in livings [and] the numbers of deaths in certain parishes in the deanery of Amoundernessโ€™.

The dispute was between Henry de Walton, archdeacon of Richmond, and Adam de Kirkham, dean of Amounderness. Adam had recently succeeded the previous dean, William Ballard, who himself had died of the plague. A jury of 18 prominent local laymen was assembled to determine the dispute, and the fact that laymen rather than the usual clerics were needed to resolve an ecclesiastical dispute is testament to the deprivations the Black Death brought to the numbers of local clergy.

Written in medieval French on the parchment recording the case are the words โ€˜dedeinz la paroche de Preston morerent treys mille hommes et femmesโ€™, which is to say that three thousand men and women died in the parish of Preston. The same figure of 3,000 deaths was recorded for both Lancaster and Kirkham parishes. This piece of parchment is the single reference that survives to the Black Death in Preston.

The 19th-century scholar who reported the discovery of the Amounderness parchment suggested the figure of 3,000 dead should be treated with caution:

โ€˜Though we have here a contemporary record, there seems little ground to place much more reliance on the numbers of deaths than on many other calculations in medieval documents. Allowance must be made for the exaggeration of panic; and there is evidently no attempt at strict accuracy โ€ฆโ€™

When the former Lancashire county archivist Sharpe France came to write his lengthy A History of the Plague in Lancashire, he put more faith in the reliability of figures, noting:

โ€˜Some doubt has been cast upon the correctness of the figures in this dispute. They are said to have been exaggerated by panic and by that inherent inaccuracy from which mediaeval calculations were liable to suffer. It must be admitted, as there were no official statistics in those days, that the total numbers of deaths in each parish were only approximations โ€” the roundness of the figures shows this. But approximations are not a very long way from being exact. The figures were provided by a local jury, and they would know only too well whether the mortality had been in hundreds or thousands, even if they did not know the figures exactly.โ€™

Sharpe France is stretching credulity somewhat when he claims โ€˜approximations are not a very long way from being exactโ€™. And if he is placing so much trust on the reliability of the lay jurors in vouching for the accuracy of the Preston figure, why does he question the figures they sign off for the other parishes? The document records 100 deaths in Ribchester, but Sharpe France notes that 110 people in the parish died with goods worth more than ยฃ5 and, extrapolating from this figure, concludes that the number of deaths must have been โ€˜at least 400โ€™. Using similar extrapolations, he ups the number of deaths in Lytham from the 140 in the document to โ€˜at least 500โ€™; in St Michaelโ€™s he increases the number of deaths from 80 to 300.

Sharpe France cannot have it both ways: trusting the lay jurors for the number of deaths in Preston and yet questioning their reliability in other parishes. A more reasonable conclusion would perhaps be that the document establishes that the numbers dying from the plague in Preston should be counted in thousands, not hundreds, but to treat the figure of 3,000 with caution.

Black Death in Florence in 1348
The citizens in Florence were filling the plague pits in their city months before the Black Death reached Preston. The Black Death in Florence, 1348; a scene from Boccaccio’s Decameron, etched by L. Sabatelli the Elder.
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:The_plague_of_Florence,_1348;_a_scene_from_Boccaccio%27s_Decam_Wellcome_V0010585.jpg

Source
All change in fourteenth-century Preston


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply