Portrait poser

Jim Burscough got in touch following the recent post on Edmund Harris. He raises an interesting challenge about the accompanying portrait: was it of Edmund Harris as captioned, or was it a portrait of his father, Robert Harris?


Edmund Harris - major benefactor of Preston charities

Briefly, I’m sorry if I’m making a mistake, but it seems to me that the photo portrait (above) is not Edmund Harris, but his father Robert:

๐Ÿ. He’s wearing a graduate’s gown and white bands, like an Anglican clergyman/headmaster. The Harris charity website says Robert had a B.D. degree. Even if Edmund was a lay reader, or similar, would he have dressed like this for an official portrait, perhaps a visiting card?

๐Ÿ. The man with the white bands looks older than Edmund’s final age of 73, e.g. his hands. Closer to Robert’s 98?

๐Ÿ‘. Your helpful link to Preston Digital Archive also leads to a Related Image (pictured) of Edmund (In his 20s? So 1820s? โ€“ for example his clothes and hairstyle?):

Edmund Harris of Preston as a young

Even allowing for age, the two images don’t look to me like the same person (but I wonder if maybe there’s a bust of Edmund at an older age, among the Victorian busts at the Harris Museum?).

๐Ÿ’. Finally, the Preston Digital Archive also offers a third portrait (pictured), a painting signed, or just inscribed, underneath ‘Your old friend Robt. Harris’:

Robert Harris - vicar of St George's Preston and headmaster of Preston Grammar Scool

To be fair, Preston Digital Archive captions the ‘bands’ photo as Edmund (but the ‘bands’ painting as Robert)! Preston Digital Archive also offers a later sketch by Furnival, for the ‘John O’Gaunt’ column in the LEP (pictured), which looks to me like a copy of the ‘bands’ painting (but identified as Edmund!):

Edmund Harris item in the Lancashire Evening Post

Sorry if this is not clear. It’s certainly far from being a matter of life and death. By the way, if you want to post any of this, please feel free. Thank you for a little hunt which has been interesting (to me).

Best wishes, Jim


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply