Joseph Garstang (1888-1928) – conscientious objector

This account of the Preston conscientious objector draws heavily on an article his great-niece Ann Berry wrote for the Documenting Dissent website and the Lives of the First World War database put on line by the Imperial War Museum. [1]

See also:
Preston’s WW1 conscientious objectors
Conscientious objectors to WW1 conscription
Great War conscription and Edwardian Preston’s ‘class ceiling’


Joseph ‘Joe’ Garstang was born on 8 October 1888 at 15 Blake Hall Street, Preston. His parents, Elisha and Jane, both worked in the cotton industry. By 1901, the family had moved to 105 Church Avenue, moving by 1911 to Chain House Farm in Ashton. Elisha Garstang was an atheist, vegetarian and early member of the Independent Labour Party (ILP).

Joe was also an atheist and member of the ILP. Before World War 1, he was working as a market gardener and fitness instructor, able to lift three men at a time (see image below). By the time he was called up in 1916 following the introduction of conscription, Joe had joined the No Conscription Fellowship and was opposed to the war:

‘Family legend has it that he said of the young men he trained as a fitness instructor, “I’m not training these lads up to be cannon fodder”.’

Joe and his family were close friends with the Preston artist and suffragette Patti Mayor, who painted his portrait. His family remember them as ‘sweethearts’.

Joe was called up soon after conscription was introduced in 1916, when he would have been twenty-six. He ignored the call up for he appeared before Preston magistrates on 16 April 1916, where he was fined 40 shillings and handed over to the military.

See also: Preston men and women who served in the first world war

He was drafted into the Loyal North Lancashire Regiment at Felixstowe. Disobeying orders led to him being court martialled on 6 May 1916 and sentenced to two years’ imprisonment. He was again court martialled on 30 December and again sentenced to two years’ jail, this time with hard labour; the sentence was commuted to six months. He served his time at Wandsworth Civil Prison and Ipswich Civil Prison.

Joe was court martialled again on 18 June 1917 and given a sentence of two years with hard labour, commuted to one year. On 14 May 1918, he was again court martialled and again given two years with hard labour. On 16 September 1918 he was transferred to what was known as the Wakefield Experiment.

The Wakefield Experiment was a now largely forgotten scheme introduced by the government to try to persuade Absolutist COs to compromise their principles. Men who had served two years in prisons around the country were transferred to Wakefield Prison, where they were offered lenient conditions in stark contrast to the hard labour they had been undergoing.

Such leniency was offered in exchange for the men working for the government. The scheme was roundly rejected by the men who refused to compromise. It proved short-lived and the men were returned to their prisons. [2]

According to the Imperial War Museum database, by January 1919 he had served more than two years in jail, with a break for ‘a three months furlough’.

Joe went on hunger strike and was force fed. His treatment became an issue that was raised in Parliament. Anne Berry provided the following account based on Hansard:

‘Joe kept up his resistance in prison. While in Ipswich gaol in January 1917, Joe went on hunger strike for three weeks, during which time he was force fed 38 times and was transferred to Wandsworth Prison hospital. The matter of Joe’s force feeding led to questions in Parliament on 2 April 1917, where Mr William Byles MP asked: ‘whether [Joe’s] health is suffering from this treatment; and why this conscientious objector is denied the protection of the Military Service Act?’ In reply, Sir George Cave said:

“This man applied to the Central Tribunal and was allowed work under civil control in lieu of military service. Having refused to take up this work in November last he had to go back to the Army and was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment for disobeying a lawful command. During the month of January he refused food and had to be forcibly fed, but he was discharged from hospital on 29th January upon his promising to behave normally, and his conduct has since been quite satisfactory.”

Joe returned to Preston after the war. He lived with his parents who took farms around Lancashire before settling in Rufford. Joe died on 22 August 1928 in Preston Royal Infirmary of septicaemia due to pyorrhoea.


A Joseph Garstang Trail was prepared in 2018 as part of the events to mark the centenary of the end of the war. The published guide contains additional information that gives an indication of the reception Joe would have received when he appeared before the Preston tribunal that decided whether men were to be exempted on conscientious grounds.

The chairman of the tribunal was the mayor of Preston, Harry Cartmell, and the trail guide quotes from Cartmell’s memoirs:: “… appellant was from the Independent Labour Party … the board deemed his objection political and not founded on real conscientious conviction (and) disallowed the claim.”

Two members of the Preston branch of the Independent Labour Party became conscientious objectors: Joe Garstang and Harry Ainsworth. Cartmell’s comment could have been directed at either, but which ever was intended, it shows they could expect little sympathy from the local authorities. [3]


Joseph Garstang before the war when he was a fitness instructor
Joseph Garstang before the war when he was a fitness instructor. https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7646268#gallery-1
Joseph Garstang (in the centre) in his role as a fitness instructor before the war
Joseph Garstang (in the centre) in his role as a fitness instructor before the war. https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7646268#gallery-3
Part of a portrait of Joseph Garstang, painted by the artist Patti Mayor.
Part of a portrait of Joseph Garstang, painted by the artist Patti Mayor. https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7646268#gallery-5
Joseph Garstang - first world war Preston conscientious objector, pictured after the war
Joseph Garstang – first world war Preston conscientious objector, pictured after the war. https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7646268#gallery-4

[1] Ann Berry, ‘Documenting Dissent | Joseph Garstang’, n.d., http://www.documentingdissent.org.uk/joseph-garstang/; ‘Life Story: Joseph Garstang | Lives of the First World War’, n.d., https://livesofthefirstworldwar.iwm.org.uk/lifestory/7646268.

[2] ‘Wakefield Experiment’, n.d., https://menwhosaidno.org/context/context_wakefieldX.html.

[3] ‘Joseph-Garstang-Trail-PrestonRemembers.Pdf’, https://visitpreston.co.uk/media/7398/Joseph-Garstang-Trail-guide-PDF/pdf/Joseph-Garstang-Trail-PrestonRemembers.pdf?m=1622033979717.

Leave a Reply