Catholics divided in Victorian Preston

I came across an interesting account of a Catholic newspaper circulating in Preston at the end of the 19th century in a book titled The Irish in the Victorian City. The authors turn to discussing the paper, the Preston Catholic News, after describing the operation of the Catholic Times, a publication that continues today and on which I worked many years ago.

The most interesting revelation, to my mind, arising from their account is the division that would seem to have existed in Preston between English Catholics and their Irish co-religionists.

The Preston Catholic News was said to have โ€˜claimed that its circulation was chiefly among English Catholics, who were superior to mere Irish Catholicsโ€™, and was accused of being anti-Irish.

It does not appear to have been supported by Preston’s Catholic clergy.

Book cover titled 'The Irish in the Victorian City', edited by Roger Swift and Sheridan Gilley, featuring a historical illustration depicting Irish individuals in a Victorian urban setting with a green background.

Hereโ€™s the section from the book (Iโ€™ve broken up the originalโ€™s two lengthy paragraphs):

A different type of limited liability company to the small one owning the Catholic Times is the broad-based kind represented by the Catholic Printing and Publishing Co., which started another Lancashire Catholic paper, the Preston Catholic News, in February 1889, with the declared aims of asserting Catholic principles, defending the Catholic Church and representing Catholic thought and opinion (C.N., 16 February 1889).

The Newcastle Irish Tribune [another Catholic newspaper] accused it of being anti-Irish, and when canvassing for advertisements to have claimed that its circulation was chiefly among English Catholics, who were superior to mere Irish Catholics (I.T., 12 October 1889).

Certainly the news columns of the Catholic News are full of Catholic news while ignoring the Irish Nationalist items which filled the Irish Tribune.

The names of shareholders listed in 1889 also bear out the suggestion of English, not Irish, Catholic backing. These shareholders included not only a broad range of Lancashire merchants and tradesmen but also a number of women, and went comparatively far down the social scale, to โ€˜Warderโ€™, โ€˜Asst. Storekeeperโ€™ and โ€˜Postmanโ€™, who held one ยฃ5 share each in 1889 (PRO: BT31 4299/27901).

One interesting omission in this list of shareholders is the local Catholic clergy โ€“ one priest, Robert Gradwell of Claughton, Garstang, held 20 shares, but he is the only member of the clergy listed in 1889, albeit an important one locally.

The company went into liquidation in 1893, but the paper survived: ironically, in view of the Irish Tribuneโ€™s anti-Irish allegations, it was brought by the Tribuneโ€™s founder, Charles Diamond, who did not want to see any useful Catholic publication collapse (C.N. 18 November 1893).

Diamond set up a new company, the British Catholic Printing and Publishing Co. Ltd., to take over the business and offered 1,000 ยฃ1 Preference Shares for subscription by Catholics who wanted the paper to remain non-political, but only 64 had been taken up by seven shareholders by July 1896 (C.N.,28 October, 18 November 1893; PRO, BT31 5614/39099).


Source: Roger Swift et al., The Irish in the Victorian City (Routledge, 2021), 172.


Discover more from preston history

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply